4 ranked finishes across 3 seasons
Only players with enough recorded history appear in the full ranking. Everyone else remains provisional.
Sport rating
The complete qualified career ranking. Ratings describe recorded results through 2025-26, not what will happen next.
Every finish is placed on the same scale after accounting for field size and ties.
Every qualified player
136 players have enough recorded history to qualify. Equal displayed ratings share a competition rank.
Eligibility: 4 ranked finishes across 3 seasonsWhole-number ratings run from 0 to 100 · 50 reflects middle-of-field performance
| Rank | Player | Rating | Evidence | Career shape | Best finish |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Josh Waidley | 67 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 5th of 126 · 2016-17 |
| T2 | Chris Lanshe | 65 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 8th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T2 | Jesse Johnson | 65 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 12th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| 4 | Ben Hodges | 64 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Below prior level lately | MLB · T1 of 185 · 2021-22 |
| 5 | Austin Hartsook | 63 | Deep record10 ranked finishes · 10 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 1st of 30 · 2013-14 |
| 6 | Nate Waldron | 62 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | Steady · Below prior level lately | MLB · 27th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T7 | Carsten Thede | 61 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Steady · Below prior level lately | MLB · 22nd of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T7 | Matt Doty | 61 | Deep record12 ranked finishes · 12 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 4th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T9 | Jack Ries | 59 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 26th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T9 | Alex Chitsazan | 59 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 1st of 88 · 2015-16 |
| T9 | Casey Keele | 59 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 7th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T12 | Ryan Austin | 58 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 15th of 126 · 2016-17 |
| T12 | Chris Pope | 58 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 9th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T12 | Chris Granger | 58 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 21st of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T15 | Dillon Tannler | 57 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 1st of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T15 | Nicholas Owen | 57 | Deep record12 ranked finishes · 12 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 2nd of 16 · 2012-13 |
| T15 | Luke Fowler | 57 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Below prior level lately | MLB · T22 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T15 | Brian Davis | 57 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 3rd of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T15 | Michael van Bronkhorst | 57 | Deep record12 ranked finishes · 12 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 1st of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T15 | Ben Marshall | 57 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · 4th of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T21 | Andrew Baker | 56 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 1st of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T21 | Derek Urbach | 56 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 18th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T21 | Tyler Thompson | 56 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 50th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T21 | Tim Neumann | 56 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · 21st of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T21 | Erik Monger | 56 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 22nd of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T21 | Jeff Hamilton | 56 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 18th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T21 | Zach McChesney | 56 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 30th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T21 | Adam Nicholas | 56 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 29th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T29 | Matt Warfield | 55 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 5th of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T29 | Steven Bryerton | 55 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 17th of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T29 | Markham Carroll | 55 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 15th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T29 | Tim Dundon | 55 | Deep record12 ranked finishes · 12 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 2nd of 30 · 2013-14 |
| T29 | Christopher Chaidez | 55 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 41st of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T29 | Dominic Russo | 55 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 7th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T29 | Carson York | 55 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 14th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T29 | Garrett Spiegel | 55 | Deep record12 ranked finishes · 12 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 5th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T37 | John Merge | 54 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 3rd of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T37 | Roy Hillman | 54 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Steady · Trending above prior level | MLB · 16th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T37 | Ron Haines | 54 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Below prior level lately | MLB · T25 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T37 | Jeff Lockie | 54 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 35th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T37 | Ryan Singer | 54 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 6th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T37 | Nick Chrisman | 54 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · 4th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T37 | Andy McCulloch | 54 | Deep record11 ranked finishes · 11 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · 7th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T37 | Rob Morse | 54 | Deep record12 ranked finishes · 12 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · T5 of 50 · 2014-15 |
| T37 | Laurie French | 54 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 8th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T37 | Brian Carroll | 54 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · 18th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T47 | Howard Sider | 53 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 20th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T47 | Billy McRae | 53 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 11th of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T47 | Patrick Burton | 53 | Deep record12 ranked finishes · 12 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · T6 of 16 · 2012-13 |
| T47 | Matthew Stephen | 53 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 9th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T47 | Alex Basile | 53 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 6th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T47 | Jeff Nesbit | 53 | Deep record10 ranked finishes · 10 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · T10 of 126 · 2016-17 |
| T47 | Niko Laron | 53 | Deep record10 ranked finishes · 10 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 1st of 50 · 2014-15 |
| T47 | Mike Basile | 53 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 53rd of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T47 | Jon Pyle | 53 | Deep record11 ranked finishes · 11 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 6th of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T56 | Alex Waite | 52 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | Variable · Below prior level lately | MLB · T17 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T56 | James Ruyle | 52 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 43rd of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T56 | Alex Brunstrom | 52 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 29th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T56 | Matt Carroll | 52 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 14th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T56 | Ryan Bennett | 52 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 28th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T56 | Ben DeJarnette | 52 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 15th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T56 | Nolan Takata | 52 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 12th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T63 | Josh Flegelc | 51 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · T17 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T63 | Josh Amunrud | 51 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 3rd of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T63 | David Menkov | 51 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 21st of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T63 | Taylor White | 51 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 17th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T63 | Eeuwout Hoogendijk | 51 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 5th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T63 | Austin Swank | 51 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · T22 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T63 | Drew Juhnke | 51 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 16th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T70 | Jason Goehring | 50 | Deep record11 ranked finishes · 11 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · 5th of 30 · 2013-14 |
| T70 | Evan Howard | 50 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 15th of 88 · 2015-16 |
| T70 | Tommy Parker | 50 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 5th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T70 | Derek Smith | 50 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 37th of 126 · 2016-17 |
| T70 | Cam Gaulke | 50 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · 27th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T70 | Jeremy Liebman | 50 | Deep record10 ranked finishes · 10 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · T2 of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T70 | Scott Schaub | 50 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | Variable · Below prior level lately | MLB · 43rd of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T70 | Kaitlin Burns | 50 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 48th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T70 | Michael Plesha | 50 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 13th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T70 | Robbie Zettler | 50 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 12th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T80 | Jordan Freeman | 49 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 25th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T80 | Jay Salato | 49 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 7th of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T80 | Griffin Dahmen | 49 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 12th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T80 | Spencer Cuiper | 49 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · 82nd of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T80 | Josh Linn | 49 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 54th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T85 | Keagen Edwards | 48 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Below prior level lately | MLB · T9 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T85 | Matt Dettman | 48 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · T18 of 126 · 2016-17 |
| T85 | Kyle Kline | 48 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · T30 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T85 | Adam Homan | 48 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 65th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T85 | Andrew Castillo | 48 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 59th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T85 | Steve Elliott | 48 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · T91 of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T91 | Steven Flory | 47 | Deep record11 ranked finishes · 11 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 2nd of 50 · 2014-15 |
| T91 | Peter Malinosky | 47 | Deep record11 ranked finishes · 11 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · T6 of 30 · 2013-14 |
| T91 | Nick Lorenzini | 47 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · 68th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T91 | Zack Reyes | 47 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 97th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T91 | Joseph Kalar | 47 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 23rd of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T91 | Tyler Elliott | 47 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 38th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T91 | Russell Eisenman | 47 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · 24th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T98 | Matt Donovan | 46 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · 75th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T98 | John Wallace | 46 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · T22 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T98 | Prithvi Muddana | 46 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Trending above prior level | MLB · 2nd of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T98 | Eric Dettman | 46 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · T10 of 126 · 2016-17 |
| T98 | Ken Van Vechten | 46 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 31st of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T98 | Paul Quiring | 46 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · 71st of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T98 | Thaddeus Wozniak | 46 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 2nd of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T98 | Tyler Urbach | 46 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 90th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T106 | Brian Jacokes | 45 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | High variance · Holding near career level | MLB · 10th of 88 · 2015-16 |
| T106 | Jordan Reyes | 45 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · T82 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| T106 | Connor Dougherty | 45 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 7th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T106 | Mike Tombasco | 45 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 39th of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T106 | Trevor Thompson | 45 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 17th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T106 | Mark Barenbaum | 45 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 39th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T106 | Joseph Williams | 45 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 30th of 126 · 2016-17 |
| T106 | Tommy Grace | 45 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 102nd of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T106 | Ryan Keene | 45 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 52nd of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T106 | Chris Juhnke | 45 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 64th of 251 · 2025-26 |
| T116 | Eric Fleischaker | 44 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · T2 of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T116 | Christopher Sokoloski | 44 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · T31 of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T116 | Jake Dolch | 44 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 112th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T119 | Scott Nittler | 43 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 98th of 233 · 2023-24 |
| T119 | Sean Richards | 43 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 45th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T119 | Nathan Clark | 43 | Deep record11 ranked finishes · 11 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · T15 of 30 · 2013-14 |
| T119 | Mrinal Bedi | 43 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 16th of 270 · 2024-25 |
| T119 | Nathan Gilman | 43 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 20th of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T119 | Patrick O'Connell | 43 | Deep record11 ranked finishes · 11 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · 20th of 220 · 2022-23 |
| T125 | Tom Sabiel | 42 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | High variance · Below prior level lately | MLB · 16th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T125 | Nick French | 42 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 123rd of 233 · 2023-24 |
| 127 | Jordan Kennedy | 41 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | High variance · Trending above prior level | MLB · 59th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T128 | Mike Bergmann | 40 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Variable · Below prior level lately | MLB · 4th of 142 · 2017-18 |
| T128 | Matthew Chaidez | 40 | Established4 ranked finishes · 4 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 43rd of 233 · 2023-24 |
| 130 | Jon Mohr | 39 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 42nd of 233 · 2023-24 |
| 131 | Jake Homan | 38 | Established6 ranked finishes · 6 seasons | Steady · Below prior level lately | MLB · 51st of 185 · 2021-22 |
| 132 | Brian Braunlich | 37 | Established7 ranked finishes · 7 seasons | Variable · Holding near career level | MLB · T77 of 180 · 2018-19 |
| 133 | Ed Maletis | 36 | Deep record9 ranked finishes · 9 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · 65th of 88 · 2015-16 |
| T134 | Brion Lee | 34 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Steady · Below prior level lately | MLB · 5th of 185 · 2021-22 |
| T134 | Joe Bergmann | 34 | Deep record8 ranked finishes · 8 seasons | Steady · Holding near career level | MLB · T101 of 126 · 2016-17 |
| 136 | Lloyd McClelland | 32 | Established5 ranked finishes · 5 seasons | Direction not established | MLB · 153rd of 185 · 2021-22 |
115 players also has a provisional rating and can enter this ranking after reaching the minimum shown above.
Board context
Recorded Baseball results first combine within each season, keeping one busy year from overpowering a longer career.
A player starts at 50 with the equivalent of four middle-of-field results. Recorded finishes move the rating up or down, and that starting pull fades as the record grows. Whole numbers keep the display honest about the archive's precision.
Only players with enough recorded history appear in the full ranking. Everyone else remains provisional.
Finishes are located within their recorded field, so results from different editions can share a 0 to 100 scale.
Ties use competition ranking. Players with the same whole-number rating receive the same number, and the next rank skips the occupied places.
Evidence depth, consistency, and recent direction explain the record beside the rating. Missing results do not help or hurt it, and recent form never turns the career score into a forecast.
Through 2025-26. Among current members whose identities are confirmed across seasons. Recorded Baseball results first combine within each season, keeping one busy year from overpowering a longer career. These are descriptive current-field career rankings, not all-time alumni rankings or forecasts.